Foucault s view on the repressive hypothesis 2026 words. Foucault and the implications ofhis work on knowledge and power compels a new understanding of the role of the intellectual, the role of the epistemologist, and a vision for the structure and aims of epistemology itself, and this paper is meant to chart out. Contents part one we other victorians 1 part two the repressive hypothesis 15 chapter 1 the incitement to discourse 17 chapter 2 the perverse implantation 36 part three scientia sexualis 51 part four the deployment of sexuality 75 chapter 1 objective 81 chapter 2 method 92 chapter 3 domain 103 chapter 4 periodization 115 part five right of death and power. Foucault argues that the main theory shaping how we understand sexuality is the repressive hypothesis 1990, 3, 10. Foucault resolves first to deal with the most overtly exclusionary mechanisms effecting discourse. The repressive hypothesis is not the whole story about how sex and power are related. According to foucault 1990, the repressive hypothesis of sexuality means that there is an assumption that there had been obstacles which inhibit forbidden sexualities, but little by little some obstacles have been removed. Certainly their presence is identifiable in the work of one such proponent whom foucault seems to have in mind, name ly wilhelm reich, especially in his socalled sexpoll writ ings of around 1930, such as dialectical materialism and. Biopolitics and the repressive hypothesis of the body.
The first exclusionary mechanisms foucault 1981 deals with are the social procedures of prohibition which correspond roughly to taboos, rituals and privileges of the speaking subject. F721 1984 194 8319510 isbn 0394529049 isbn 03947400 pbk. May 08, 2007 the repressive hypothesis is found in michel foucault s history of sexuality vol 1, in which he examines the functioning of sexuality as an analytics of power related to the emergence of a science of sexuality scientia sexualis and the emergence of biopower. It revolved largely around the concept of power, rejecting both. Foucault and deleuze on sexuality and desire, critical. Pdf this essay examines the foucauldian foundations of queer theory in the work of eve kosofsky sedgwick. Counter intuitively deconstructing the repressive hypothesis, foucault claims that sex and sexuality was not conceived in the vein of a discourse until the 17th century. Chapter one will discuss foucaults concept of the repressive hypothesis which he develops in the first volume of the history of sexuality entitled an introduction 1990. As such, foucault s concept of power stands in opposition to the repressive hypothesis, a perspective which conceives of power as domination, coercion, and the suppression of desire and truth, operating by way of law, taboo, and censorship dreyfus and rabinow 1982. It shows that this freudian moment in foucault mitigates his criticisms of the repressive hypothesis, but it also suggests a conception of interiority that can be interpreted as.
But although foucaults rhetoric at times seems designed to obscure this obvious rejoinder, it. The repressive hypothesis holds that we struggle to liberate ourselves from the imposition of silence and tight sexual morals. Foucault suggests the repressive hypothesis is essentially an. Foucaults 1990 criticism of the repressive hypothesis is wellknown. Introduction to michel foucault, module on the repressive. Foucault was mostly interested in the discourse of sex rater than studying the actual history of sexuality, he looked at the way people talked about sexuality during history. Foucaults critique of marcuse jeffrey renaud university of ottawa in the history of sexuality, volume one, michel foucault ostensibly sets outto reject the repressive hypothesis as an inadequate characterization of the relationship between sex, power and knowledge. The essay argues that sedgwicks increasing disappointment with foucaults critique of the repressive hypothesis is in part produced by the slippery rhetoric of the history of sexuality, vol. But although foucaults rhetoric at times seems designed to obscure this obvious rejoinder, it is not one that need unduly concern him. As such this is his last book covering the complex machinations of biopower and discourse, this time considering.
Rethinking the repressive hypothesis foucaults critique of marcuse. Repression has psychological connection and it an attempt of a person in which he repels his desires towards pleasurable instincts by excluding the ones conscious desire and. In questioning the repressive hypothesis, foucault is not primarily interested in contradicting it, and he certainly does not want to deny the fact that, for instance, sex has been a taboo subject in western culture. In foucault s words, the repressive hypothesis is merely that western man has been drawn for three centuries to the task of telling everything concerning his sex. This form of repressions parallels the rise of the bourgeosie in the seventeenth century because it was against their ethic and they didnt. In this connection, i will address foucault s central claim that marcuse operates with a purely nega. The history of sexuality, volume 1 begins with an account of the repressive hypothesis, foucaults term for the widespread idea that modern society continues to struggle with the legacy of 19thcentury sexual repression. According to foucault, proponents of the repressive hypothesis operate with a number of unacceptable assumptions. Manufactured in the united states of america first edition text design by marsha cohen. Presentation on mf history of sexuality volume 1 pp. As such, foucaults concept of power stands in opposition to the repressive hypothesis, a perspective which conceives of power as domination, coercion, and the suppression of desire and truth, operating by way of law, taboo, and censorship dreyfus and rabinow 1982. Repressive hypothesis holds that through the european history, human beings moved from the society where the lively talk and expression about sex and sexuality were freely expressed, into the period where all these free expressions were repressed and became forbidden. This essay will explore foucaults view on the repressive hypothesis, exploring whether he believes repression exists.
The history of sexuality is a fourvolume study of sexuality in the western world by the french. Foucaults overall response to the repressive hypothesis the repressive hypothesis is not the whole story of the relationship between power and sex for the last 200300 years 1012 trying to liberate our true, natural sexual identities from repressive power ignores how those identities themselves are produced by a. In the history of sexuality, volume one, michel foucault ostensibly sets out to reject the repressive hypothesis as an inadequate characterization of the relationship between sex, power and knowledge. Michel foucaults term for the perception, which he demonstrates is historically false, that the victorian era was silent on the issue of sex and sexuality. Foucault argues that we generally read the history of sexuality since the 18th century in terms of what foucault calls the repressive hypothesis. His interest is primarily the discursive fact of sexuality. It shows that this freudian moment in foucault mitigates his criticisms of the repressive hypothesis.
We other victorians in part one, foucault discusses the repressive hypothesis, the widespread belief among late 20thcentury westerners that sexuality, and the open discussion of sex, was socially repressed during the late 17th, 18th, 19th and early 20th centuries, a byproduct of the rise of capitalism and bourgeois society, before the partial. Rethinking the repressive hypothesis e g sexuality, volume one, as well as the series of interviews that sur rounded the publication of this text. This paper focuses on foucaults account of internalization. Hello, im trying to clarify my understanding of foucault s writing, in history of sexuality, on the repressive hypothesis. Hes trying to situate the repressive hypothesis in a larger context, a larger discourse around sex. As such this is his last book covering the complex machinations of biopower and discourse, this time considering their operations on the body within the sphere of sexuality. In volume 1, foucault criticizes the repressive hypothesis, the idea that western society.
The repressive hypothesis is found in michel foucaults history of sexuality vol 1, in which he examines the functioning of sexuality as an analytics of power related to the emergence of a science of sexuality scientia sexualis and the emergence of biopower. The era that was famously so morbidly fearful of the merest hint of sex that it covered the legs of pianos lest they call to mind naked human legs was as this very example illustrates obsessively concerned with sex. Foucault s 1990 criticism of the repressive hypothesis is wellknown. So, in victorian times, the prevailing discussion was that sexuality was repressed and foucault looked at why people were saying that. The incitement to discourse from the history of sexuality, vol. Foucault begins his study by presenting what he calls the repressive hypothesis of the history of sexuality. Mar 14, 2015 a video in which i discuss who i have been reading over the past few months. Repressive hypothesis holds that through the european history. The will to knowledge, a short book exploring what foucault called the repressive hypothesis. Foucault repressive hypothesis by jay shier on prezi.
Foucault, freud, and the repressive hypothesis article in journal of the british society for phenomenology 452. Repressive hypothesis it is a fallacy to believe that the victorian era marked the beginning of sexual repression. The essay argues that sedgwicks increasing disappointment with foucault s critique of the repressive hypothesis is in part produced by the slippery rhetoric of the history of sexuality, vol. Contents part one we other victorians 1 part two the repressive hypothesis 15 chapter 1 the incitement to discourse 17 chapter 2 the perverse implantation 36 part three scientia sexualis 51 part four the deployment of sexuality 75 chapter 1 objective 81 chapter 2 method 92 chapter 3 domain 103 chapter 4 periodization 115 part five right of death and power over life 3. Studying cloud 9 through foucaults repressive hypothesis helps show a representation of bettys desire for sex and the acceptence of sexual expression thanks to the impact of science and politics within the twentieth century. What is important in foucaults notion is that while one. Michel foucault, a french philosopher, argues that the history of sexuality since the 17th century has maintained a repressive view, which foucault refers to as the repressive hypothesis sparknotes editors, n. In the history of philosophy, many philosophers discuss the repression, however freuds and foucaults repression hypothesis are widely remains under the debate. In this connection, i will address foucaults central claim that marcuse operates with a purely nega. The repressive hypothesis is the idea that what we would conventionally call modernity roughly the 18th century through today is characterized by a widespread societal repression of sexuality. My understanding is that foucault negates the idea the sexuality in the modern era was repressed and suggests that through categorisation of various sexual practices a variety of discourses have arisen around the subject of sex. In foucaults words, the repressive hypothesis is merely that western man has been drawn for three centuries to the task of telling everything concerning his sex. For foucault, biopower is sort of like a technology of power, which is to say, a way of exercising.
Vol 1 of the history of sexuality was written just before a significant shift in foucaults thought. By rejecting the repressive hypothesis it was not foucault s intention to deny misery and repression in capitalism. It revolved largely around the concept of power, rejecting both marxist and freudian theory. The repressive hypothesis makes it seem both defiant and of utmost importance to our personal liberation that we talk openly about sex. The history of sexuality is a threevolume series of books written between 1976 and 1984 by french philosopher and historian michel foucault. Foucault raises three doubts about this repressive hypothesis. Hello, im trying to clarify my understanding of foucaults writing, in history of sexuality, on the repressive hypothesis. Mar 21, 2011 in repressive hypothesis, foucault talks about the repression of sexuality throughout history. By rejecting the repressive hypothesis it was not foucaults intention to deny misery and repression in capitalism. In repressive hypothesis, foucault talks about the repression of sexuality throughout history. He basically mentions that the main reason of this repression is the power which prohibited sex to be formed as a discourse.
Foucault rejected this repressive hypothesis and claimed that evidence from the 19th century pointed not to a prohibition on speaking about sexuality but to a remarkable proliferation of discourses about sexuality. Chapter one will discuss foucault s concept of the repressive hypothesis which he develops in the first volume of the history of sexuality entitled an introduction 1990. What foucault was trying to reject by the rejection of the repressive hypothesis was the totally negative conception of power where power is conceived simply in negative terms as a limiting, repressing, force. A video in which i discuss who i have been reading over the past few months. The repressive hypothesis the grand aim of all science is to cover the greatest number of empirical facts by logical deduction from the smallest number of hypotheses. The repressive hypothesis is part of that discourse. Michel foucault s term for the perception, which he demonstrates is historically false, that the victorian era was silent on the issue of sex and sexuality. According to common wisdom, we witness an increasing discourse of repression that develops hand in hand with the rise of capitalism, culminating finally in the pervasive stereotype of the victorian as imperial prude foucault, history of sexuality 1. Accordingly, foucault believes, they adopt the traditional view of the. This form of repressions parallels the rise of the bourgeosie in the seventeenth century because it was against their ethic and they didnt want to ruin their families lineage.
Specifically, foucaults use of free indirect discourse in that volume destabilizes both the theory of repression and the critique. History of sexuality, volume 1, part two, repressive. Foucault, freud, and the repressive hypothesis request pdf. The history of sexuality, volume 1 begins with an account of the repressive hypothesis, foucault s term for the widespread idea that modern society continues to struggle with the legacy of 19thcentury sexual repression. The repressive hypothesis supposes that since the rise of the bourgeoisie, any expenditure of energy on purely pleasurable activities has been frowned upon. Repressive hypothesis holds that through the european. Contents the carceral 234 space, knowledge, and power 239 biopower 257 right of death and power over life 258 the politics of health in the eighteenth century 273 sex and truth 291 we other victorians 292 the repressive hypothesis 301 practices and sciences of the self 331 preface to the history of sexuality, volume ii 333. Before this point in history, sex was largely ignored by state powers. Foucault suggests the repressive hypothesis is essentially an attempt to give revolutionary importance to discourse on sexuality.
521 463 154 709 428 1264 219 863 743 970 204 689 207 379 1474 877 192 633 846 383 121 486 844 1275 909 1342 371 929 272 551 325 644 951 94 1124 29 482 281 852 765 1484 363